![]() |
| My favorite picture from my 33rd birthday: A selfie of a selfie of a selfie |
An as avid consumer of online media, this article gave me pause. The fact that I found this article through a link on a friend's Facebook page also contributed to my aforementioned ruminations (apparently today is $5 word day in Holly's world). After a great deal of thought, I've reached a few conclusions, and, in the grand internet tradition, I present them below in a fabulous list format.
1. Screen time enables lifelong learning.
I am a lifelong learner. I consider a day in which I don't learn something new as a wasted day. I often find myself pulling up Google on my phone, my tablet, or my computer, searching something I've just read or seen or heard. To borrow from Ms. Turkle, I might be the woman at the Lincoln Memorial with my phone out. I might be searching something about Lincoln's life, the ramifications of his actions, or his long-term impact on our country. Or I might be making a note to do a more detailed search on a specific Lincoln-motivated subject when I have more time.
2. Pictures tell the best stories.
When I was five, my parents loaded my brother and me into the backseat of our Honda Civic hatchback and, together, we set out on a four week exploration of the American West. Armed with my brand-new camera, I set about documenting our adventure, as only a five-year-old can. I had the first roll of film taken before we turned off our road. For weeks, we explored purple mountains majesty and amber waves of grain. We saw Old Faithful, Mt. Rushmore, the Tetons, the Bad Lands, and so many more iconic American destinations. And for all that adventure and all those sites, can you guess which photos are most often shared? Photos of the back of my dad's head as we pulled out of the driveway. Pictures of my brother pretending to be a dinosaur in front of, well, anything he happened to be in front of. Portraits of my beloved stuffed cat, Spot, posed in front of majestic landscapes or our little family car. These are the images that spark our memories, invoke our emotions, and, ultimately, detail our family's Western Odyssey. I can promise you, had our family adventure taken us to the Lincoln Memorial, our photo album would include a picture of a plush feline posed in front of our venerable 16th President, accompanied by another photo of a three-year-old boy, claws up and fangs bared, ready to trample all over any predator, from the Cretaceous period or otherwise, who would dare threaten Honest Abe.
3. Restricting screen time and modeling responsible screen time are two different things.
I cannot imagine pulling out my phone when I'm sitting at my parents' (or grandparent's) dining room table. It's not because I've been forbidden from using my phone. I could probably live-tweet dinner with Grandma and no one would argue with me. Well, maybe my poor Twitter followers. No, my family wouldn't blink at my phone being at the table. But my phone would never be at the table. I've been taught, more like raised, to understand that dinner time is family time and few things are as important as family. Furthermore, I'm lucky enough to work in a field in which nothing I do is so critical that it can't wait an hour. As a result of my upbringing, I know how to put down my screen(s) and enjoy face time with those I love. Do I tweet over lunch? Sometimes. Do I text with one person while talking to another? Occasionally. But when it matters, when it's more important for me to be in the room than online, I naturally put down the phone and pick up the conversation. That's how I was raised, no restrictions necessary.
I think the point of my response is to remind Ms. Turkle, and anyone else, that a photo, a Tweet, or a status update represent a moment in time and not the cumulative impact of the experience.
Does my selfie in front of a movie marquee lessen my enjoyment of the movie?
Nope.
Does my status update about my favorite musician's music being integrated into my favorite television show lessen my appreciation for either?
Not at all.
And does the picture of President Obama posing for a selfie with Prime Minister Cameron and Prime Minister Thorning-Schmidt represent the sum total of the president's experience at Nelson Mandela's Memorial Service?
Absolutely not.
No one but that individual can judge the impact of an experience. What our pictures and updates, texts and tweets, do is share that experience in the hopes to also share the impact.












